
In this post, I will be quoting from ‘Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: The Hidden Epidemic’ (1992) by Jesse A. Stoff. I began reading this book after the middle of summer had passed, and it was the second book about ME/CFS that I finished reading. While it remains one of my favorite books about the illness, I don’t like everything in it. Since there is still no cure, just as there wasn’t one in 1992, the author unfortunately mentioned a number of wacky treatments and spent a lot of time writing about the importance of willpower in curing the illness, which is ridiculous. “Holistic medicine is an approach to health care that addresses the entirety of the individual affected and his or her life circumstances. If we look at someone in a holistic, nonjudgmental way, we can observe four levels of functioning. First, and most obviously, we can touch, see, and hear the physical body. This is a very important aspect of human health because it is on this level that the Immunologic-viral war is ultimately fought. It is also the level that is most accessible to testing, that lets us most easily monitor the raging battle. Viral titers closely approximate the level of functioning of the physical body during the battle. It is at this physical level that nutritional supplements and medicinal herbs act to reinforce the ailing defenses of the body. Unlike drugs, which are given for their own intrinsic effect (i.e., an antibiotic is given specifically to kill a bacterium and does nothing to help – and in fact may hinder – the body’s own defenses), natural medicines act in harmony with the body to strengthen the Immune system and bring equilibrium to the metabolism. For example, the medicinal herb Echinacea, when prepared and administered correctly, has a powerful effect in stimulating the macrophages—the garbage collectors of the immune system. The physical body and its biochemistry have further importance in that it is here that the other levels of human functioning become visible. Less visible, but no less Important, is the doing-will function of a person. Doing-will is what provides the oomph to get out of bed in the morning. Owing to the tremendous drain on the body’s energy-will reserves by the immune system as it battles the virus, a sinister feeling of lethargy creeps in. A correlation between such lethargy and abnormalities in liver function blood tests is often clearly seen. The overwhelming fatigue destroys the victim’s stamina and with it the energy to work and to lead a normal life. Some victims – the special victims, like Charlie – are able to maintain enough of their motivating goals to overcome the erosion of the will. Emotion is the next level of human function. Many chronic diseases have a component of depression associated with them. Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is no exception; accompanying depression often proves to be the rule. As a result of the immunologic turmoil caused by the virus(es), the body will often produce antibodies against its own thyroid gland. This results in a slowing of the metabolism and a sense of doom and depression that threatens to engulf the victim in a shroud of hopelessness, moodiness, and irritability – feelings that are often directed toward those most loved. Finally, we come to the paramount level of human function, that of cognitive activity. Here the processes of memory and the ability to concentrate and think linearly are often compromised. The Epstein-Barr virus can attack the brain and in doing so will impair the cognitive functions. Thus, we can see the potential for this virus to wreak havoc on the four levels of human functioning, or “members.” The physical body tending to disintegrate in a sea of inflammation, the doing-will activity paralyzed and wanting, the emotions overshadowed by despair, and the cognitive functions threatened to the point that the victim loses the ability to express his or her individuality. CFS is a sinister and powerful foe, yet with a commitment by patient and physician to a comprehensive and holistic approach, it can be successfully fought off and its symptoms completely reversed. By addressing and supporting the four members of human functioning, a victim may not only overcome the present challenge to his or her health but can gain new and useful insights that may lead to a more fulfilled and happier life in the future. This coordinated approach includes a nutritional regime along with specific techniques and exercises to bolster the will, lighten the moods, and sharpen the mind, as outlined in chapters 7 through 9. Viruses can be viewed as wandering collections of genes. They are not merely carriers of mononucleosis, chronic Epstein-Barr syndrome, and random death. They are compulsive communicators. From the very begining, from Day One, they have migrated from protocell to protocell, and finally from organism to organism, passing on snatches of genetic information. Sometimes they peel away a string of DNA from you or me and carry it away into the air. Viruses pass from humans to cats to seagulls and whales, with the result that the chromosomes of certain cats bear genes that can be found in the DNA of monkeys and baboons, and appear also in a particular virus. From kittens to fireflies to weeds, into the sea and back again, the viruses wander without aim, snipping off a piece of heredity here, depositing it there, exchanging the code of life like bits of gossip passed over a backyard fence. Watching a cauliflower mosaic virus transfer firefly genes to a tobacco plant, and then seeing the plant acquire the glow-in-the-dark characteristics of the firefly, one wonders how much of our evolutionary history derives from “something in the air.” Millions of years ago, it seems viruses spirited away the normal genes that regulate the rapid-fire growth of embryonic cells and are permanently shut off later in life. Carrying these displaced pieces of genome in tow, the viruses dropped them off from time to time in human chromosomes, where they traveled down with sperm and egg to the first cell of the newborn. Researchers have uncovered dozens of these stray genes – called oncogenes – that appear to trigger runaway cell growth when they are switched on. The cells become expanding spheres of flesh – colonies from which highways soon branch. Centuries ago, Hippocrates opened a cadaver and discovered such colonies. The highways radiating from them looked to him like crab claws, and he named the condition after the Greek word for crab – which came into the twentieth century as “cancer.” Viruses needn’t splice genes in the wrong place to throw an orderly biology into a chaos of cancer cells (somewhat as if you were to randomly splice snippets of a Ramones concert onto a recording of Beethoven’s Ninth, or vice versa). Viruses can incite cancer right on the spot, all by themselves. Scientists learned this from David, “the boy in the plastic bubble.” David suffered from a rare genetic defect that left him powerless to produce antibodies. Outside of the ultrasterile environment of his specially constructed bubble, he was doomed by the air we breathe. In an attempt to provide him with the natural defenses most of us take for granted, a bone marrow transplant was attempted in 1983. But blood cells in his sister’s marrow contained minute traces of the Epstein-Barr virus, as does the blood and marrow of almost anyone who has lived past the age of thirty, we now know. Within days, David’s blood was roiling with the most extreme Epstein-Barr activity in the history of medical experience. One week later, the first cancer cells appeared in his lymph glands. They formed tumors in almost no time at all. Within four months he was dead. The Epstein-Barr virus, once thought to be harmless, has since been associated with an immune cell cancer (Burkitt’s lymphoma) that usually is found in children. The virus is also known to play a leading role in a deadly and horribly disfiguring cancer that strikes the noses and throats of some fifty thousand people a year. MIT biologist Nancy Hopkins comments, “Cancer arises from a number of insults to the DNA. Viruses are one insult. They start the ball rolling.” Treating the cancer-triggering virus may prevent it from making the insult, meaning that we might fight cancer before cancer cells actually exist. In studying the virus, we enter a world more fascinating than science fiction. Picture an organism so strange that many evolutionary biologists have trouble accepting it as “alive.” The Epstein-Barr virus cannot even reproduce itself unless you insert it into a living cell. Once inside, it hijacks the cell’s chemical machinery, adding its own genes to the genes of the infected cell, so that the protein and nucleic acid producing factories of the cell treat the viral DNA as if it belongs there. Copy after copy of new viral DNA accumulates in the cytoplasm (the clear, watery fluid within the cell), to become packaged with ever-growing supplies of viral proteins. The population of virus particles doubles, and doubles again. And the center of infection is in certain white blood cells called B cells, the very cells that are supposed to make the antibodies to kill the virus. Once the Epstein-Barr virus enters the body, whether it triggers full-fledged mononucleosis or merely a sore throat (the soreness is the outcry from nerves bundled around cells torn open and leaking new virus particles), it lingers forever. In most cases it remains hidden in the B cells. Only those virus particles remaining latent inside the B cells, those particles that have ceased reproduction, shut off most of their genes, and made themselves “invisible” are able to survive the initial assault by the immune system. But every so often a B cell will transform into a virus factory, expelling new virus particles into the blood. More often than not, the particles will attract immediate attention – by the Immune system’s formation of antibodies – to themselves and be destroyed. A day, a week, or a month later, another B cell will swell and spew virus particles. It is as if the viruses are testing the water. Sometimes they win. Sometimes a little piece of the host’s immune system shuts down – the very piece that recognizes the virus or produces a specific antibody against some portion of it, such as the honeycomb-shaped viral capsule. The virus has then passed successfully through a kind of natural selection filter, and finds itself immune to immunity. Since 1984, researchers have been discovering connections between Epstein-Barr virus and various chronic and relapsing symptoms. In a study published in the January 1985 issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine, some eighteen clinical features of EBV are outlined, including prolonged and debilitating fatigue (the most common symptom), intermittent low-grade fever, sudden onset of multiple allergies, chronic sore throat, swollen glands, difficulty in concentrating, arthritic symptoms, migraines, and psychological disturbances (particularly depression, which may derive from experiencing the other symptoms). Cases are now being diagnosed in numbers dwarfing the AIDS (acquired immune deficiency syndrome) epidemic, including clusters in Nevada, Hollywood, and Manhattan. It’s beginning to look as if we are in the midst of a spreading plague; but perhaps it only looks that way. Possibly, large numbers of cases are now being identified primarily because the condition was never recognized before. Until 1984 people simply suffered from constant and inexplicable fatigue along with some combination of the other symptoms of chronic fatigue syndrome, or they developed lymphatic cancer or nasal pharyngeal cancer or yeast infections or one of several varieties of neurological complications (including a chronic pain syndrome, such as reflex sympathetic dystrophy). All of these symptoms are but the footprint of CFS. The disease itself saps physical, mental, emotional, and immunologic strength. It may be progressive and unrelenting, and the ultimate scope of the problem is still unknown. The news is not all bad, however. The following chapters present guidelines that will enable patients and physicians to identify the syndrome and, once it is identified, provide a safe and effective therapeutic strategy that will strengthen the victim’s immune system to the point where the virus goes into remission and stays in remission – perhaps permanently. There are three possible responses to a viral assault on the body. Initially, the immune system responds homeostatically: it tries to correct the imbalance (for example, with increased numbers of white blood cells) and then return everything to the status quo. This approach works well for most threats. However, in the susceptible individual an episode of CFS proves to be so overwhelming to the homeostatic mechanisms of the Immune system that outside help is needed; hence, the other two possible responses. The first way in which help can be given from outside the body is through drugs. Drugs are hyperpurified, “dead” substances that act directly and specifically on the disease process itself, rather than by strengthening the body’s natural defenses against disease. There are no drugs presently known to be effective against EBV or most of its partners in crime. There is, nevertheless, another possible response – the holistic one. We can stimulate the immune system to a heightened level of competence that will not merely beat back the virus but will leave the body more resistant to disease in general. In other words, the body itself is enlisted as an active participant in its own defense. The holistic approach utilizes therapeutic agents including diet, exercise, vitamin supplements, and prescription natural remedies (homeopathic medicines). It also requires the patient to assume a measure of responsibility for his or her own recovery. The relationship between the patient and the physician thus becomes a partnership in an approach that ultimately makes the science of medicine more humanly relevant. Under an electron microscope, the Epstein-Barr virus looks more like a collection of machine-made parts than a creation of carbon chemistry. Proteins have been shaped into hollow tubes, hexagons, and equilateral triangles. The virus’s genetic code is enclosed in a doughnut-shaped core. Its genome consists of 170 kilobase pairs. For those familiar with computers, this would be comparable to 170 K of memory, or slightly less than the amount of information programmed into most of today’s arcade computer games. Virtually everyone is eventually infected with EBV. It comes to life the moment it makes contact with the skin cells lining the mouth and throat. From there it spreads to the B cells in the blood, which circulate through the body, churning out virus-attacking antibodies. Most people beat back the virus with no ill effects; but once infected, they are infected for life. Even in its dormant phase, the EBV genome becomes a permanent fixture in the genome of the B cells, dividing with them into succeeding generations, and waiting patiently for the ever-watchful immune system to be weakened by other diseases, old age, overwhelming stress, or by such unnatural influences as alcohol, cocaine, and marijuana abuse for a chance to reemerge. From its outpost in the mouth, EBV spreads among children via shared lollipops and other less-than-sanitary eating habits, and among adults by kissing and shared dining utensils. According to some estimates, nearly 100 percent of the population is infected by age thirty. The incidence of a constellation of EBV-type symptoms that simply refuse to go away exhibits the pattern of a rising epidemic. Between 1984 and 1987, the number of patients appearing in doctors’ offices with the same devastating symptoms doubled, then doubled again, and has been doing so since the condition was first noticed in 1977. The pattern of increase is hauntingly similar to the AIDS outbreak.”

















